GDPR-compliant in the cloud: Where is my data?
|
Reading time 6 minutes
"Our data stays on our server." I hear this sentence frequently in conversations with managing directors. The underlying message: The cloud is insecure, our own server is secure. This perception is understandable – but it is no longer true.
Having your own server in the basement is not automatically more secure than a professional cloud solution. Often, the opposite is the case. But the concerns are real, and they deserve an honest answer.
The biggest security risk is not the cloud
The most common IT security incidents in medium-sized enterprises share a common cause: outdated software without security updates. The Windows Server 2012 in the basement that's "still running". The firewall whose firmware hasn't been updated for three years. The backup that nobody tests.
Professional cloud providers invest more in security than most medium-sized companies ever could: redundant data centers, automatic backups, encryption at rest and in transit, 24/7 monitoring, dedicated security teams.
That doesn't mean the cloud is automatically secure. It means that the question "Cloud or local?" is the wrong question. The right question is: "Who operates my IT infrastructure more professionally – myself or a specialized provider?"
Where your data actually resides
When it comes to cloud storage, the server location is crucial – for both legal and practical reasons.
Nextcloud as a document management system can be hosted with German providers whose servers are located in German data centers. This ensures that only German data protection laws apply. A Data Processing Agreement (DPA) governs how the host handles your data. You retain full control.
ERPNext can be hosted either with a European cloud provider or on your own server. The decision depends on how much IT expertise is available in-house and how critical the data is.
Onshape stores data in AWS data centers. For pure CAD models, this is generally unproblematic. For particularly sensitive documentation – such as customer contracts or manufacturing documents containing personal data – I recommend storing the exported files in Nextcloud rather than directly in Onshape.
Understanding the Shared Responsibility Model
A common misconception: "If my data is in the cloud, the cloud provider is responsible for security." That is only partially true.
Cloud security operates on the Shared Responsibility Model:
The provider is responsible for:
Physical security of data centers
Infrastructure availability
Network security
Basic encryption
You are responsible for:
Access rights and user management
Strong passwords and two-factor authentication
What data you upload
Compliance with industry regulations
A secure cloud provider is of little use if all employees use the same password and sensitive drawings are sent by email.
GDPR and US cloud services: What changes in 2025
The legal situation regarding US cloud providers has become complicated. The EU-US Data Privacy Framework of 2023 was intended to provide legal certainty, but political developments in the US have created new uncertainty in 2025. German cloud providers like Nextcloud report a tripling of inquiries since the beginning of the year.
For mechanical engineering companies, this specifically means:
Pure CAD models without personal data are less critical
Documentation containing customer data, employee data, or trade secrets should reside with European providers
Data Processing Agreements must be kept up to date
When in doubt: choose German servers
Nextcloud as a GDPR-compliant foundation
Nextcloud is an open-source platform for file storage and collaboration. The advantage over services like Dropbox or Google Drive: You decide where the servers are located. With a German host offering ISO 27001 certification and a DPA, you are on the safe side.
What Nextcloud offers:
File synchronization like Dropbox, but self-hosted
Shared folders with permission controls
Full-text search in documents
Integration with office applications
Mobile apps for iOS and Android
For mechanical engineering companies, Nextcloud is the sensible storage location for technical documentation, customer files, and exported CAD data. Integration with Onshape and ERPNext ensures that released drawings and bills of materials automatically land in the right folder.
The backup question: Cloud vs. Local
An argument often made for local servers is: "I have control over my data." But control also means responsibility – for backups, for redundancy, for disaster recovery.
Questions you should answer honestly:
How often are backups performed? Daily? Weekly?
Where are backup media stored? In the same building as the server?
When was the backup last tested? Does the recovery actually work?
What happens in the event of a break-in, fire, or water damage?
Professional cloud providers replicate data across multiple geographically separated data centers. An outage at one location has no impact on availability. Achieving the same level locally would require substantial investment.
A pragmatic cloud strategy for machine builders
The question is not "Cloud yes or no", but "Which data belongs where". A sensible strategy for mechanical engineering SMEs:
To the cloud (with a German/European provider):
Active working data and documents (Nextcloud)
ERP data for location-independent access (ERPNext)
CAD models for teamwork (Onshape)
Locally or in a specially secured cloud:
Archived legacy projects with high confidentiality value
Data subject to contractual confidentiality obligations
Mission-critical backups as an additional layer of security
The next step: An assessment of your current data management shows where risks lie and which cloud strategy fits your company.